Skip to main content

Insight vs Concentration

One occasionally hears today, from a variety of different sources, that the Buddha taught two different forms of meditation: one is referred to as concentration, the other as insight. Concentration is a practice wherein the mind learns to settle and maintain awareness on a single, reoccurring event, such focusing on the breath or by repeating metta phrases; this practice is regarded as the most efficient route of developing states of tranquility and single minded focus, known as jhana. Insight is the process of developing enough bare attention—i.e. freedom from distracting thoughts and perceptions—to allow the mind to observe any internal experienced from an unbiased, neutral perspective. The mind is free to move from object to object—it doesn’t stay pinned as in concentration—noting the impermanence and lack of lasting, underlying identity inherent to each event that arises in life. The detached view this observational state entails ultimately results equanimity, which we’re informed is the way to liberation from suffering.

Yet the Buddha never taught insight without concentration; in fact he presented the two as complimentary companions. If we want to end suffering then, in addition to cultivating harmless behavior, we should develop both: “When a practitioner develops tranquility together with insight the path is born. Peace comes from following that path and developing it.” (Yuganaddha Sutta).

If we single-mindedly practice concentration without insight, we may find ourselves blissed out, but we’ll also find that bliss framed by dark shadows of repressed, challenging underlying energies, such as sadness, fear, loneliness and depression that we’re avoiding while staying with the breath. Psychological healing from early woundings requires open awareness. In other words, concentration can be a kind of spiritual bypass.

On the other hand, if we single-mindedly practice insight without equal measures of concentration, our spiritual practice will turn needlessly dark and dry; for in observing our lives in terms of impermanence, we’ll find ourselves feeling groundless and lost, until the breakthrough comes when we attain full equanimity; insight alone leaves us stuck amidst a lot of phenomena that arises and passes. That’s not a lot of joy there to say the least. Mixing both concentration and insight, however, allows us to grow spiritually while experiencing the bliss of focused attention.

Now, let’s finally examine why a day at the beach feels so good: we sit in a folding chair, feeling the warmth, relaxing the body, hearing the sounds of the waves arising and passing, our thoughts of work and life’s dramas miles away, back in the city so to speak. But while the beach, sand, sunshine and ocean are conditional, and subject to specific conditions—ability to take a day off from work when its sunny and warm—the real underlying states that create the bliss of the beach can actually be recreated virtually anywhere on any day. We can sit in a chair, feel the outline of the body, relax the body and note the arising and passing sensations of the breath, while putting aside life’s dramas for awhile.

If we use insight to investigate what makes the impermanent experiences of life—an afternoon on the beach, a new relationship, relaxing into the couch after a long day, etc—feel so good, we can then use concentration to recreate the inner states and bring joy into the rest of life, when the external conditions are less pleasing. And so, when it comes to practice, when it comes to concentration or insight, my question is: Why not both?

Josh Korda, april 15, 2014

Comments

  1. I think that the English translation of "samadhi" into "concentration" may be part of the confusion since the original terms has probably different connotations than what our notion of concentration. However, some Theravada Schools have long taught that its is important to develop insight before moving to the jhana states. Hence "mindfulness" is the seventh and "concerntration" the eighth of aspect of the path. It makes sense to me. I can enjoy relaxation, a focused mind, have some kind of extatic experience through meditation without much personal and social development in my life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very Interesting information. Every parents should enrol their child in any best memory training course. There are many organisation provides brain development program for kids in India.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

fear

There are times in life when intrusive, fear based thoughts latch hold of us, filling the mind with swarming, buzzing thoughts, distracting us during interactions with others, muting the sensory richness of each moment—the sounds, body sens ations, aromas, feelings and on. Such dire visitors—generally based on past resentments or speculative fears—can easily bait and hook us, threatening us with annihilation, repeating constantly; given how constant the messages can be, releasing such thoughts can feel like ignoring ‘the world is going to end’ new flashes on CNN or city sirens announcing impending hurricanes. The mind can really play tricks that make it all to easy to abandon the present, which is, of course, the only place of true safety and utility. When we find the mind latching onto these narratives, images or moods, and we can’t reassure, reason with or let go, sometimes the only solution is to give up the battle and actually write down what our fears are trying to tell us. If

5 ways to resist obsessive thoughts (Vitakkasanthana)

The mind can be thought of as a committee Our thoughts are present by many "voices," some skillful and unskillful W there are some skillful voices in there, focusing on useful ideas, there are also the many voices in the "committee" that cause us suffering by advancing and encouraging useless, stress inducing ideas, plans, worries. Some examples of unskillful, stress producing obsessions —are dedictated to figuring out the worst possible outcomes (fear) of any situation —fixate on unknowable future events, i.e. what will we experience later in life? —try to figure out what other people are thinking about us —compare ourselves with others, especially in material concerns in general, the buddha broke these down the thoughts of craving, aversion and delusion. How unskillful internal voices persuade us some of these committee members try to get their way by —most work by repeating the same thought over and over —some split into thousands of variations that seem differe

Integrating the Head with the Heart

Integrating The Head With The Heart Summary of Insights Winter 2016 - Josh Korda ~ I’m an empowered Buddhist dharma teacher, which means I spend a lot of time addressing groups of students, in the course of annual retreats and two or three weekly classes around Manhattan and Brooklyn; however, the focal point of my life’s work involves providing one-on-one spiritual and psychological mentoring to individuals. What’s of central importance to my interpersonal work is emotion integration, by which I mean the practice of bringing one’s underlying, spontaneous, instinctive feeling states into ongoing conscious attention and decision making. Now, you may well wonder, why would anyone need help perceiving or assimilating emotions? Aren’t they readily apparent? However, I’ve found, over the course of working in depth with hundreds of individuals, that many of us live at estranged distances from our authentic feelings, depending on strategies of denial, numbing, and